Advertisements

Winning Putt (Episode 93)

THE GRINDSTONE TRIBUNAL:

The fun dies fast. Come see what Dreskar, Dobar and myself though of this game, if I didn’t make it painfully obvious in the video…

Dreskar:
This is going to be a simple one for me. The answer is no, don’t even look at the damned thing. Oh sure it is an okay to average golfing game, and you can get a few laughs out of playing with friends. That being said this is the most shamelessly cash grab, pay to win fuck you game I have played in a long time. Namco Bandai stooped down to such levels of greed and stupidity that I could never, ever recommend this to anyone regardless of how good the game may be. Fortunately the game isn’t all that great, and is just average so you aren’t even missing out on anything special, unless you like horrendous voice work, ugly texture work and visuals and a convoluted mess of a game. If you do like those, you can easily look elsewhere to get your kicks and leave this game to the waste bin where it belongs.
Recommended?:  FUCK NO

Dobar:
By the time this is posted, Winning Putt will be off my computer.  I was sorta looking forward to this review and had fun for a little while, but the problems mounted with this game.  Trying to hit an accurate shot is nearly impossible, some holes are impossible to birdie for a non-cash shop player starting out, and the ugly graphics just pop out once you look into it.  While I had fun playing with Grindstone, I think I would have had more fun with almost any other multiplayer game.  Playing solo was a chore and while I had a great match with someone much higher level than me, where I choked on the last hole to lose the match, I know that I was lucky.  This game is such a pay-to-win piece of garbage that I would not recommend anyone play this game.  The actual golf is not fun and while I may not have ran into the pay-to-win crowd, I know I would have eventually ran into them.  I honestly might put this game lower than Swordsman as my worst game we reviewed this year, it is not a good game at all.
Recommended?: NO, not even with friends. Almost any game is better.

ChaosD1:
“This is going to get worse before it gets better.”
I’m waiting… just WAITING for some dipshit to rag on this video because I didn’t get to a high enough level, as if that somehow fixes the omnipresent technical issues and gameplay issues this game has at its core. I’m honestly appalled at how badly this game runs, because I don’t remember even a quarter of these issues during the beta. Hell, I think I had to convince the rest of Grindstone to at least keep playing when they found out it was golf back in the “Project: New Sky” days, as they also were consumed by the golf game stigma. I was just looking for another Pangya alternative. I don’t feel too many companies have fun with the sport, or genre. At least not as an MMO.
But what Winning Putt has become I cannot forgive in any form. It runs like trash, it’s physics are complete nonsensical garbage, performance issues render the game unplayable for the absurdly unforgiving and precise swing/hit mechanics. Pay-to-Win shouldn’t be a fucking thing AT ALL. Whether or not its unquestionable inclusion bugs you, or the community’s rejection of it shows an attitude that’s unwilling to accept it, it still exists. Did you even SEE how broken and fucked up this game looks? Grass growing through staircases and golf balls? Trees growing in the middle of the road? Ugly floating textures? Stolen, poorly cut logos, including the Raspberry Pi logo?! Why give us a massive lobby to explore if you’re just going to include nothing in it but fucked up textures and mapping that would have probably looked ok ONLY as background decoration? Isn’t all this unnecessary asset rendering basically killing the performance enough already?
This is a game I found to be Birdemic levels of amusing at first, but only made me more angry the more I played it. You can tell when watching my streams from the first day to the last.
We get a new golf game backed by a publisher that has brought us classic franchises, like Pac-Man and Tekken, and new classics like Dark Souls and Dragon Ball Xenoverse, yet the game plays and looks like a shit-tier Chinese knock-off and Pangya is the one getting shut down? God damn this shithole of a year.
Recommended?: NO. Hell, fuckin’ no.

Advertisements

Posted on November 30, 2016, in Episodes and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 3 Comments.

  1. I guess it’s the definition of precision and fun that makes all the difference. Sure I noticed the textures. I noticed the shimmering bricks at the base of one of the buildings in the square. I noticed the stance of the golfers in some situations. I even noticed the grass growing out of the golf balls at times. My biggie is, so what? In other games, such as Obivion, Fallout 3,4, New Vegas, and a host of other games, the problems existed. The answer here was to allow players to mod the game and fix the problems. I don’t think we should mod MMOs, especially like golf (sports). It would have to be so limited – fix textures, fix speeds, allow different hats and stuff, maybe even special golf balls after being approved. But this would make the game prettier, perhaps, a bit more playable. My thing is that about the only things I have found I just want to scream at are 1) when the putts don’t break as they should, and 2) when shots randomly stray a bit more than should be possible given the situation and the stats of player and clubs. If those two things were even 50% fixed, i would love this game. As it is, I really like it. It’s fun, it’s reasonably representative of a real golf game. I play in High school extensively and had all kinds of things happen. You know if the ball is only hit a few inches too hard, it is technically impossible for it to completely roll over the hole and not drop in. Nor can the ball sit 2/3 of the way into the cup and not drop. Those small things irritate me. I hit a 50ft putt, it misses by less than 1 inch yet it stops hanging over the edge of the cup or bounces into the cup and back out to land on the edge of the cup. Not physically possible! But, all in all, I have enjoyed the heck out of this game and would recommend it. A cash hog? Yes, most certainly. However, I simply play to see just how far I can go on what gold I receive in the game. Mostly that seems good. I have had 3 hole-in-ones, 2 of those in the same day. I have shot -4 under par on 9 holes. I have only a few holes that I can’t very well birdie, but who makes a par 3 that is 240 yards? Really now for Very Easy? lol, I can’t dive over 225 at my level 28 unless there is a strong back wind and it is downhill. Sorry this is so long, but wanted to say all of it.
    Again:
    Yes, would recommend, but there are issues…
    Scott

  2. hey look the voice cast from might no 9

  1. Pingback: The MMO Grinder 2016 Year-In-Review | MMO Grinder

Leave a Reply (New user comments must be approved before appearing.)

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: